If you're searching for the best salt water taffy flavors, having access to solid recommendations can be incredibly helpful. With over 95 flavors available, we suggest checking out our top 10 best-selling list before you make your next taffy purchase. Based on actual sales data from our store, these are the flavors Americans buy the most. It doesn’t matter if you’re buying for yourself or as a gift; our fact-based list below makes discovering all the best flavors most people genuinely love easier! However, we understand that you won’t agree with them all, so to keep the conversation going, let us know if your favorite taffy flavor made a list and if not, let the world know the one that makes your heart sing; you never know you may inspire!
1. Assorted Taffy Flavors
Our 16oz jars of individually wrapped assorted salt water taffy provide a diverse mix of popular flavors, offering something for everyone, including you! Perfect for those who are undecided on a favorite flavor. Plus, with 12 flavors, it’s our #1 best-seller here at Taffy Delight. With several sweet, fruity, and creamy varieties to discover, this original mix is ideal for anyone seeking a full range of versatile flavors, including unique options such as frosted cupcake and cotton candy! Each piece is soft, chewy, and freshly whipped to perfection, just the way you love!
Flavors Included - Banana, Grape, Orange Cream, Raspberry, Watermelon, Cherry, Chocolate, Cinnamon, Frosted Cupcake, Cotton Candy, Caramel Apple, and Strawberry Cheesecake.
2. Black Licorice Swirls
Next up on our list are our 16oz jars of individually wrapped Black Licorice Swirl taffy! The nostalgic black-and-white swirls offer a captivating visual appeal that matches its flavor—made specifically for those who love soft, chewy salt water taffy and, of course, licorice! So, if that’s you, click below and discover what makes our black licorice swirls our second best-selling flavor here at Taffy Delight.
3. Peanut Butter Taffy
Many will debate that peanut butter taffy should be #1, which we agree with; however, it came in third place. As for why we agree, well, there was a shortage of this flavor earlier this year, and as a result, we were out of stock for nearly a month, so that may have made a difference in today’s post; nonetheless, it’s still one of the best-selling salt water taffy flavors in the United States, but then again, who doesn’t love peanut butter taffy? Click below to give it a try!
4. Buttered Popcorn Taffy
Buttered Popcorn Taffy is perhaps the most surprising flavor on our list. This isn’t your ordinary flavor; nonetheless, it’s the fourth most-purchased taffy flavor in our store! After curiosity led to a taste, it’s safe to say that this flavor lives up to its name; it’s sweet, creamy, and magically tastes precisely like buttered popcorn! Each piece is individually wrapped and comes in a 16oz jar, which is more than enough for movie night.
5. Sugar-Free Assorted Taffy
For all those who love sugar-free taffy, which many people do, this assortment was exclusively made with you in mind. Our one-of-a-kind 16oz jars include popular sugar-free flavors such as banana, chocolate, cinnamon, raspberry, strawberry, and vanilla! According to customer reviews and first-hand experience, these sugar-free taffies are just as sweet, soft, chewy, and delicious as the original assorted taffy mix, which ranks #1 on our list of the best taffy flavors!
6. Banana Taffy
You’re either a fan of banana taffy, or you’re not. That said, most of our customers purchase this flavor, which is why it’s #6 on our list of best-selling Taffy Delight flavors! Once you get to the tenth flavor, you will also notice that this ranking isn’t a coincidence. So, if you’re a fan of soft, creamy, chewy banana taffy, you’ll love our large 16oz jars of only your favorite taffy flavor! Made with love in the United States, you can order your supply by clicking below and owning the moment; you deserve it.
7. Peppermint Taffy
Taffy Delight Peppermint Taffy ranks as one of the best-selling flavors here in our salt water taffy store, as do all of the flavors on our list, which is why they’re on our list, to begin with! However, like all taffy flavors, you either love this one or you don’t. As for those who don’t, we can’t speak for you, but for those who do, we totally understand and get it. For those who don’t know, this is the freshest, softest, creamiest, chewiest taffy you will ever try! To experience all the hype and what makes this flavor a top seller, click below, order, and let us know what you think!
8. Blueberry Taffy
We'll never understand how Blueberry Taffy ended up #8 on our list. That said, as the author of this article, I’m going to respond to you in first-person now because this is my favorite taffy flavor of all time, and I think it should be #1, despite the data! However, that’s just my opinion, and this list is built of facts, so we’ll take #8 out of the 98 salt water taffy flavors we offer here in our store! So, for anyone who loves this flavor, has never tried it, or has had a disappointing experience with another brand, we recommend giving Taffy Delight Blueberry Taffy a try; you’ll never settle for less again, I promise!
9. Chocolate Taffy
Once again, Chocolate Taffy is #9 on our list of best-selling salt water taffy flavors here at Taffy Delight. It’s another flavor that deserves to be in our top ten, but the people have spoken; therefore, she stands where she stands, and rightfully so! Again, 9 out of 98 isn’t bad; it’s excellent, which is why it’s on our list. However, once more people discover our sweet, soft, creamy chocolate taffy, this flavor is going to the top! To help make that happen, scoop up a 16oz jar of it today, making its way one step closer to leading the pack!
10. Sugar-Free Banana Taffy
As mentioned before, it was no coincidence that banana taffy ranked #6 on our list; here is the proof. Coming in at #10, we have the one and only Taffy Delight Sugar-free Banana Taffy, which sends a message that banana-flavored taffy is, without debate, one of America’s favorite taffy flavors, and the numbers prove it. We would’ve loved to have excited you with a new flavor, but after looking at the numbers, we couldn’t deny our sugar-free banana taffy the glory! Not to mention, when you combine both options, sugar and sugar-free, banana is the #1 best-selling taffy flavor in America!
What’s Your Favorite Salt Water Taffy Flavor?
We understand that salt water taffy flavors are a personal preference and choice; not everyone will agree with our list, not even us, but based on sales data, these are the top 10 best-selling taffy flavors here at Taffy Delight. Furthermore, since we have all taffy flavors, it proves that these ten flavors are America’s favorites, not just in our store but in all stores nationwide!
On that note, we’d like to know your favorite taffy flavors! If you had to make a top 5 or even a top 10 list, what would it taste like? You can also connect with us on Facebook and be the first to know about new taffy flavor releases and sales! Share your opinions in the comments below, and in a year from now, including every year after that, let’s look back and see how our list stood against the test of time!
Leave a comment
All comments are moderated before being published.
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.